Tonight’s song is a list of funny compliments. The singer tells the girl he loves what she could have been: a candle, because she is so bright, for example.

Learn from Songs · Unit 8: Modals · B1
A Motown classic, sung by UB40 with a reggae beat: could have been for imaginary possibilities (you could have been a candle), the way you…, and playful comparisons with like and as… as, with Philo, Sophia, Marcos and Demetria.

Tonight’s song is a list of funny compliments. The singer tells the girl he loves what she could have been: a candle, because she is so bright, for example.

A candle? That’s a strange compliment.

That’s the fun of it. Each one is a joke and a compliment at the same time. And each one uses could have been.

Demetria, you could have been a trumpet, the way you shout at me.
Detroit, 1964, and Birmingham, 1990
The song was written by Smokey Robinson and Bobby Rogers of the Miracles, and in 1964 it became the first hit for the Temptations, on the Motown label in Detroit. It was full of clever, playful comparisons, which was Smokey Robinson’s speciality.
UB40 are a reggae band from Birmingham, in England, named after the form unemployed people had to fill in. In 1990 they recorded the song for their album Labour of Love II, an album of songs they loved, and their reggae version reached the top ten in America.
In the song, the singer tells the girl that she could have been all sorts of things, because of the way she does the things she does: she is bright, sweet and clever, and she sweeps him off his feet.
A good compliment makes people smile.
Listen: the compliments

Listen once. How many things could she have been? Why?

Then answer Section A. Listen for the reggae rhythm.
Could have been: imaginary possibilities

You could have been a candle (you’re so bright). You could have been a teacher (you’re so clever).

could have + past participle = it was possible, but it didn’t happen: She could have been a doctor, but she chose music. In the song it is a playful way of praising someone.
The way you…

I love the way you smile. It’s the way she talks that I like.

the way + subject + verb = how someone does something. I don’t like the way he speaks to his sister. No “how” after the way: not “the way how you smile”.
Like and as… as

Your eyes are like stars. You’re as bright as a candle. You’re as sweet as honey.

like + noun for comparisons; as + adjective + as for things that are equal. Some are fixed: as cold as ice, as busy as a bee, as light as a feather.
Sophia’s comparison: the Song of Songs

The Song of Songs is full of comparisons like these: your eyes are doves, your hair is like a flock of goats coming down the mountain, your teeth are like newly washed sheep.

Goats and sheep! And Sappho said a bride was like a sweet apple, high on the highest branch, that the apple-pickers forgot. No, not forgot: they couldn’t reach it.

I think I prefer the candle.
Sophia’s summary
| Words and forms | Use | Example |
|---|---|---|
| could have + past participle | possible but didn’t happen | You could have been a teacher. |
| the way + subject + verb | how someone does something | I love the way you smile. |
| like + noun | comparison | Your eyes are like stars. |
| as + adjective + as | equal comparison | as bright as a candle |
| as cold as ice, as busy as a bee | fixed comparisons | He’s as busy as a bee. |
Listen to the song for Section A, then do the rest. Press “Check my answers” at the end. You can try again as many times as you like.
Listen to the song and choose the best answer.
1. What is the song?
2. Why could she have been a candle?
3. Who first had a hit with the song?
4. Who wrote it?
5. What kind of band is UB40?
6. What was the album called?
Write the missing word or words.
7. You could have a teacher. (be)
8. I love the you smile.
9. Your eyes are stars.
10. You’re as sweet honey.
11. She could have a doctor, but she chose music. (become)
12. Brr! My hands are as cold as .
Is the sentence correct English?
13. “I like the way how you laugh.”
14. “You could have been a singer.”
15. “She’s as tall like her brother.”
16. “He could have went to university.”
Discussion and writing
Compliment chain. Give the person next to you a playful compliment: You could have been a…, the way you… They thank you and pass a new one on.
Discuss. 1. Is it easy for you to give or receive compliments? 2. What is the nicest compliment you have ever had? 3. What could you have been, if your life had been different?
Write (100–120 words). Write a short, funny poem or letter for someone you admire (a friend, a grandparent). Use could have been, the way you…, like and as… as.