Tonight’s song is very short and very simple: a man remembers the last time he saw the woman he loved, crying in the rain as they said goodbye. He knew they would never meet again.

Learn from Songs · Unit 12: Review · B1
Willie Nelson’s simple, beautiful version of an old country song: the future in the past (I knew we would never meet again), past simple and past perfect for memories, someday and will for hope, with Philo, Sophia, Marcos and Demetria.

Tonight’s song is very short and very simple: a man remembers the last time he saw the woman he loved, crying in the rain as they said goodbye. He knew they would never meet again.

That’s so sad.

Sad, but full of hope at the end: someday, he says, they will meet again. Listen to how simply Willie Nelson sings it.

Short songs are good songs.
Texas, 1975
The song was written by Fred Rose, a songwriter and publisher in Nashville, and first recorded by Roy Acuff in the 1940s. For thirty years it was a quiet old country song.
Willie Nelson, a songwriter from Texas, recorded it for his album Red Headed Stranger (1975), with only his voice, his old guitar and a few instruments. The record company thought the album sounded unfinished. But “Blue Eyes Crying in the Rain” became his first number one country single, and won him a Grammy.
In the song, he remembers how they kissed goodbye and parted. He knew they would never meet again. But he believes that someday they will walk together again.
Some goodbyes are not the end.
Listen: the memory

Listen once. What does he remember? What did he know? What does he hope?

Then answer Section A.
The future in the past

I knew we would never meet again. She said she would write. I thought it was going to rain.

When we talk about the future from a point in the past: would (the past of will) or was / were going to. I knew he would come. It is also how reported speech works: “I’ll write” → She said she would write.
Past simple and past perfect

We kissed goodbye and parted. I had never felt so sad before.

Past simple for the events in order; past perfect for something before that moment: I had never felt… = up to that time.
Someday, will, again

Someday we’ll meet again. One day it will stop raining.

someday / one day + will for a hope about the distant future. Careful: someday (one word) = at an unknown time in the future; some day (two words) also exists: Let’s meet some day next week.
Sophia’s comparison: Jacob and Joseph

When Jacob was told that his son Joseph was dead, he refused to be comforted. He thought he would never see him again. Twenty-two years later, he held him in his arms in Egypt and said: now I can die, because I have seen your face.

And Odysseus’s old dog Argos waited twenty years. When his master came home in rags, nobody knew him, except Argos, who wagged his tail and died happy.
Sophia’s summary
| Words and forms | Use | Example |
|---|---|---|
| would + infinitive | future seen from the past | I knew we would never meet again. |
| was / were going to | future in the past (plans) | I thought it was going to rain. |
| past simple | events in order | We kissed and parted. |
| past perfect | before that moment | I had never felt so sad. |
| someday + will | hope for the distant future | Someday we’ll meet again. |
Listen to the song for Section A, then do the rest. Press “Check my answers” at the end. You can try again as many times as you like.
Listen to the song and choose the best answer.
1. What does he remember?
2. What did he know?
3. What does he hope at the end?
4. Who wrote the song?
5. Which album was it on?
6. What did the record company think of the album?
Write the missing word or words.
7. I knew we never meet again.
8. She said she write. (will)
9. I thought it was to rain.
10. I had never so sad before. (feel)
11. we’ll meet again. (at an unknown future time)
12. We kissed goodbye and . (part)
Is the sentence correct English?
13. “I knew she will come.”
14. “Someday we’ll meet again.”
15. “He said he would call.”
16. “I had never feel so sad.”
Discussion and writing
Predictions from the past. Think of when you were small. What did you think would happen? I thought I would be…, I knew I was going to… Were you right?
Discuss. 1. Why are simple songs sometimes the most moving? 2. Do you believe some goodbyes are not the end? 3. Why did the record company not understand the album?
Write (100–120 words). The last time. Write about a goodbye (real or imagined). Use the future in the past (would, was going to), the past perfect and someday.